Aid Groups Slam Trump's Gaza Peace Plan as 'Displacement by Design' Following Humanitarian Failure


This story, titled "‘Displacement by design’: Trump’s Gaza peace plan a failure, aid groups say" First published on Al Jazeera English and was retrieved from its original source on November 19, 2026.
Our site bears no responsibility for its content. You can review the details of this story at its original source.
One year after the United Nations Security Council endorsed the Trump administration's 20-point Comprehensive Plan to end the Gaza Conflict, a coalition of five major international aid organizations—the Danish Refugee Council, Norwegian Refugee Council, Oxfam, Refugees International, and Save the Children—has released a scathing assessment. The coalition's humanitarian scorecard graded the plan just four out of 26 possible points, giving it a zero for humanitarian access and only one point for civilian protection.
The report comes as Israeli forces launch a new ground offensive in central Gaza, advancing tanks west of the "Yellow Line" and issuing forced evacuation orders in violation of the peace plan. According to OCHA, the Israeli military's control of Gaza territory has expanded from 58 percent at the start of the ceasefire 13 months ago to 65 percent today, while Israel itself claims control of 70 percent of the territory. This expansion has confined approximately 2.1 million Palestinians to an area as small as 109 to 128 square kilometers, creating extreme population density.
Ramy Abdu, founder and chairman of the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, warned that Israel is engaging in the unlawful acquisition of territory by force. The human cost has been severe, with at least 1,650 Palestinians killed and 5,975 wounded since the October ceasefire. Shaun Hughes, World Food Programme (WFP) country director for Palestine, noted that the military control makes it nearly impossible for residents to grow food or fish, leaving over 80 percent of the population unemployed and dependent on aid.
Lilu Thapa, executive director for the Middle East, Asia and Europe at the Danish Refugee Council, described the situation as "displacement by design," arguing that a ceasefire allowing such confinement is a ceasefire in name only.
The Board of Peace and International Stabilization Force (ISF), established by President Donald Trump, has also faced intense criticism. Ramy Abdu told Al Jazeera that the Board, which lacks meaningful Palestinian representation, has become a "political shield" for Israel's occupation and a form of "functional normalisation of genocide and starvation." Mohsen Abu Ramadan of the Palestinian NGOs Network echoed these sentiments, stating the Board has failed the international community.
The humanitarian crisis has deepened due to a severe aid blockade. While the peace plan required 600 UN-coordinated trucks daily, an average of only 49 entered in September. Most of these lacked medical supplies, with Israeli authorities prioritizing commercial trucks carrying expensive goods. Jan Egeland, CEO of the Norwegian Refugee Council, and Abby Maxman, Oxfam America President, both attributed the suffering to deliberate policy choices made by Israel, the US, and the UN.
As Gaza enters its fourth winter, the shelter crisis is critical. Despite $18bn pledged via the Board of Peace, reconstruction has not begun, and 1.4 million Palestinians live in makeshift shelters. Recent storms have caused deaths and flooded thousands of tents, while 150,000 tents and 500,000 blankets remain blocked at the border. Inger Ashing, CEO of Save the Children International, stated that children are now colder, hungrier, and more traumatized than before.
Jeremy Konyndyk, president of Refugees International, called on the US and UN Security Council members to use their leverage to ensure obligations are met. Meanwhile, Gaza's health ministry reports that 2,027 patients have died while awaiting medical evacuation. Ramy Abdu suggested paths toward accountability, including ICC arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and ICJ genocide proceedings.
When contacted by Al Jazeera, Brad Klapper, head of communications for the Board of Peace, provided an official report that acknowledged implementation failures but blamed Israeli political indecision. The report stated that the absence of decisions by the Israeli government regarding the return of civilian police and the entry of the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza (NCAG) and the ISF has impeded the plan. The Board concluded that a ceasefire delivering nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely.
Politics
Politics
Politics
Politics