Pete Hegseth Faces Continued Scrutiny After Blocked Impeachment Vote


This story, titled "‘Not an acquittal’: After impeachment vote, Hegseth still under microscope" First published on Al Jazeera English and was retrieved from its original source on November 19, 2026.
Our site bears no responsibility for its content. You can review the details of this story at its original source.
Following the United States midterm elections, the future of Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth remains uncertain as new Democratic majorities prepare to take office in Congress. The former Fox News host has faced increasing demands for his removal, though analysts debate how an impeachment would impact military policy under President Donald Trump.
Jasmine El-Gamal, a former Middle East adviser in the Pentagon, noted that while the secretary of defense is a powerful figure in shaping conflict, targeting Hegseth alone may not ensure accountability for decisions such as the US-Israel war on Iran. She argued that Hegseth works closely with the president and his advisers, stating that viewing him as a mere executor understates his power, while calling him the sole architect ignores the president's role.
Since taking office on January 25, 2025, Hegseth has managed several controversial international campaigns, including the war on Iran and boat strikes in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific Ocean, both of which have been accused of violating international law. The Iran war became a significant political liability for the Republican Party during the midterms, with a poll showing 44 percent of voters were less likely to support candidates who backed the conflict.
The Democratic Party achieved a major victory in the November 3 midterms, flipping both the House of Representatives and the Senate. Shortly after, outgoing Republican Congressman Thomas Massie led a push for impeachment, filing eight articles of impeachment that included accusations that Hegseth dismantled safeguards for civilians, contributing to the bombing of an elementary school in Minab, Iran, which killed at least 120 children. However, the Republican lame-duck majority in the House blocked the measure on November 10 with a 211 to 204 vote.
Hegseth is not the first Pentagon chief to face pressure after a poor election for his party. In 2006, following a similar midterm rout over the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, President George W Bush announced the resignation of then-Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld.
Hegseth has remained defiant, dismissing critics as "deep-state radicals" in a video posted after the midterms. He urged the military to "stay the course" in the war against Iran, asserting that the administration is more determined than ever to finish what they started.
Internal party criticism has also emerged, with Vice President JD Vance stating on social media that the war was the "real reason" Republicans lost the midterms. Additionally, former US diplomat Hala Rharrit, who resigned in protest of the US involvement in Israel's genocidal war on Gaza, suggested that Hegseth was critical in guiding the Iran war's most divisive moments, including the initial strike lists for the Minab school bombing.
Brian Finucane, a former State Department legal adviser, suggested the midterm results reflect a backlash against the Trump administration's use of executive power. He noted that under the Constitution, the bulk of war powers belong to Congress. Incoming Democratic leaders, including Hakeem Jeffries, have pledged to check Trump's war-making powers and remove Hegseth from office.
Despite the blocked impeachment, El-Gamal cautioned that the vote was not an acquittal. She pointed to congressional investigations and the "power of the purse" as other means to hold Hegseth and Trump accountable, anticipating that the new Congress will continue to pursue allegations of war crimes in Iran and elsewhere.
Politics
Politics
Politics
Politics